Skip to main content Skip to search Skip to main navigation
Please feel free to contact us via our order hotline:
07626 974 9700
(Mon-Fri 8am-8pm, Sat 8am-12pm)

How not to do it

News

The Homeopathic Prescription - How Not to Do It

By Margaret Tyler 

 

[EDITOR’S NOTE – In a summary of the most frequent mistakes made by those who embark on their homeopathic careers without a solid grounding, Dr Tyler vividly describes what can regrettably happen in such cases; at the same time she offers tips on how to avoid these and other errors successfully.]

 Praxisleitfaden-Homoeopathie-Margaret-Lucy-Tyler.12926.jpg

Dr Kent, Dr Gibson Miller and others can tell us, from their many years of experience and numerous successfully resolved cases, how best to do it. I count myself among the highly qualified and can tell you, after several years of only moderately good prescriptions and many failures, exactly what one should not do.

I used to be overwhelmed with exhilaration and joy when I had found the right remedy. Happily, that happened often enough to keep the enthusiasm for the work alive in an optimistic person like me. But on closer inspection it becomes clear that in many cases I had failed completely. In the hope of helping others in the same situation, I will try to put my failures down on paper.

Homeopathy – as you and I know – has worked well in the past and continues to do so today. At that time I had not yet mastered it. My ideas were far too crude, my methodology too haphazard and unstructured, and consequently it worked only sporadically. The power was there, as could be seen from one or two successful prescriptions, but I could not reliably and automatically call on it at any time. I did not yet possess the calmness and purposefulness of those who not only understand the forces they work with, but also know their laws, their limits and the peculiarities of their manifestations.

In short, I had not understood the matter and did not command the philosophy behind it… To be frank, I had no idea that there was such a thing as a philosophy. Without the corresponding philosophy one can use homeopathic remedies – even as a practitioner – but one is by no means a homeopath and will never achieve homogeneous and consistently satisfactory results. One will not even be able to assess the results one sometimes obtains and react appropriately.

IF YOU WANT TO MASTER SOMETHING, YOU MUST FIRST SUBMIT

One should always remember that the most important aspect of power is the ability to tame and direct it into the right channels. For that, one must be able to submit to the laws governing it. Electricity, for example, is undoubtedly a very powerful form of energy that even the greatest sceptic does not deny. But to make use of this tremendous energy we must harness it in accordance with the laws of nature; we must submit to its peculiarities, learn and study it, and use it according to its own dictates. Only when one has understood and internalised its laws can one employ it for the benefit of humanity.

With homeopathy it is the same. There are no simple rules of thumb. A child can experiment with a flint and produce sparks, but that does not mean it could rely on that spark as a dependable source of power, for to do so it would need to know and apply the laws of nature precisely.

No mighty force of nature works without its corresponding laws and limitations; these must be considered or we will fail lamentably.

Homeopathy is like electricity: it follows an all-or-nothing principle! Both forms of energy are only visible by their results. And in both there is no half measure. The methodology must be sound if you wish to obtain consistently good and reliable results. The occasional spark – which can also be destructive – is by no means success. To be convincing in your work and to improve steadily, you should know how to use the spark. That requires method.

PRESCRIBING BY DISEASE

The first and often fatal step for many homeopaths is prescribing according to diseases. One knows the disease and finds the remedy that fits it.

One knows Rhus and Bryonia as ‘rheumatic’ remedies and swings, as it were, between the two. If these remedies then do not cure a case that in fact demands Sulphur or Tuberculinum or even the dentist, homeopathy is blamed.

One knows that Sulphur and Graphites are so-called ‘skin remedies’, but they do not help some patients (and they are not few) for whom Pulsatilla would be indicated.

One dismisses Sepia as a ‘woman’s remedy’ and scorns anyone who dares to give it to an infant. And this, although in homeopathy one should prescribe solely on the basis of individual indication.

A tuberculous dactylitis perhaps, which was cured precisely with Sepia!

A goitre with a hard nodule in the right lobe – not even the left – which was cured with Sepia (I recently presented such cases at the British Homeopathic Society).

Or an obstipation that was cured with Rhus or even Variolinum (see Dr Burnett).

Or (one of my colleagues recently managed this) a case of nocturnal gastralgia with emaciation that was cured with a single dose of Syphilinum.

If you want to do it right and achieve regular success, you must leave the disease alone and concentrate on the patient. Then you should not say “Here I have a case of rheumatism and because Rhus is a good remedy for rheumatism I will try that,” but rather “Here I have a Sepia patient in front of me and therefore she needs Sepia, whatever disease she is suffering from.” If only I had known that at the start of my career!

And don’t be tempted to say “I tried to solve this case homeopathically, but homeopathy could not help.” Remember: you failed, not homeopathy. The energy, the power was there, only you did not know how to apply that energy. Once you can admit that, you know the limits of your own knowledge.

GIVING REMEDIES TOO FREQUENTLY

The second, no less fatal, mistake is hidden in the mysterious abbreviation t.d.s (ter die sumendum), which the experienced among us reserve exclusively for placebo. I believe this abbreviation has ruined more homeopaths than one can imagine.

Close behind in second place is the absurd magic formula of those who call themselves first-rate homeopaths: ‘once a week’. When I began my steep career of wrong prescriptions and failures, it was fashionable above all to treat chronic cases with t.d.s doses. Imagine that! And because I had never learned how to prescribe properly, I fell headlong into the trap. My mother, who had learned good homeopathy, protested in vain! “You can’t do that,” she said to me. “It is not right to take remedies daily for weeks on end. That is not homeopathy. As soon as an improvement can be seen, the remedy must be stopped immediately. It should only be given again if the symptoms recur unchanged.”

But t.d.s was so en vogue that I decided to continue prescribing that way. I knew how my C30 and C200 potencies worked and prescribed them once daily or one to three times a week, according to whim. Naturally, I did not consider at the time that if one plays the t.d.s game, one should prescribe the remedy in material doses – say a D3, in which there is still enough material to produce crude effects but not cause major harm. With this method one can obtain fairly good, albeit superficial, effects.

Worse: I led other homeopaths into doing the same and prescribing high potencies in frequent doses. I often wondered myself when, after a seemingly good prescription, the patient returned and reported: “For the first three days I thought I was cured. I felt so well.” But then it went downhill or new symptoms appeared for which I again had to find a new remedy, and again with the same result.

The patients always felt better at first, then it became worse and sometimes just a little different, but they were never cured!

Ladies and gentlemen, one can work like that for years and ‘cure’ one’s patients over many years. Each time they will forgive you the setback after the first three days. They will even be grateful and attribute the bad days to their own disease. Thus a veritable vicious circle arises: initial improvement; remedy effect; new prescription which makes the symptoms disappear; new symptoms appear; a new remedy is given, again with initial improvement; then the same mistake is committed once more and new symptoms appear again, briefly relieved by yet another dose. Thus it goes on, one enters a dreary prescribing cycle and at the same time the esteem for homeopathy declines. And young homeopaths wonder because the enthusiasm for their vocation has somehow been lost. Even with my rather limited knowledge at the time I could have done much good and prescribed brilliantly if I had given my patients the advice I heard from my mother so often: “As soon as you feel better, you must not touch your medicine again, unless you experience a definite aggravation.”

I fear I corrupted several of my colleagues by introducing them to the higher and highest potencies. I know I make myself look bad by my confessions, but perhaps it is necessary. For the mistakes I made in my great ignorance live on in some corner of the London Homeopathic Hospital and confront me again and again, usually at inopportune moments – hinc illae lachrymae!

I have seen a colleague who, as he put it, “wanted to experiment with the higher potencies,” prescribe Calcarea carb. CM, to be taken three times daily for a month.

And my own recommendation to take Tuberculinum weekly – in addition to, say, Silicea C30 t.d.s (of all remedies Silicea, this deep-acting remedy with an action of 40–60 days!) – still haunts me like a malicious spirit that I cannot easily dispel by an afternoon of remorse and penance.

THE REPERTORY

In my endeavours it was not solely a matter of imagination and rash experiments; of course I also endeavoured to work up my cases, which is by no means self-evident. I prescribed the wrong remedy, which is also not self-evident. Often I would sit and work on a case for hours and it would often be for nothing! After all, no one had shown me how to do it.

Until the first teachers from America came to us, I did not know how to recognise the valuable symptoms that can be decisive for the case. No one had shown me how to exclude certain remedies and simplify the work by concentrating on the general symptoms that stand out in the patient. I had no idea how to focus my working time.

As a rule I began my case analysis by making a list of the remedies that – take for example – are given for constipation. Thus I worked through all the symptoms, important and unimportant; even mechanical complaints were thrown into the equation and probably led me astray more often than I like to admit. Afterwards everything was evaluated purely arithmetically. I never asked myself the question (and it is indispensable) whether patient and remedy matched. Occasionally I found a good remedy, but the work itself was dreadful, monotonous and did not even pay off in great cures, let alone financially.

But I did not give up: I was determined to master the art of repertorisation and reduce my own workload. I even went so far as to devise a sophisticated system of index cards – each symptom had its own card, the corresponding remedies were diligently punched. I have punched thousands of cards until my ears rang. I still have them, a whole cupboard full. But even my index cards could not help me, because the system was wrong.

When you know how a good repertorisation works, a small portfolio of about 80 cards with ‘general’ symptoms is sufficient to begin case analysis. Often one needs no more than five minutes and a brief glance at the materia medica for the case analysis. If only I had known that! One thing I have learned from my experience: I am competent enough to teach everyone how not to do it.

There is another approach to repertorisation (which should actually make our work easier and rule out inappropriate remedies) that reliably leads to failure: by not starting with the general symptoms, but listing all remedies that could be considered for the patient’s complaint. Take, for example, my Sepia case that was cured with a single dose of Sepia.

In the days when I repertorised aimlessly and without direction I would have begun by listing all the remedies that might be considered for a goitre. Then I would have made another list and excluded all the remedies that do not affect the right half of the body or the right side of the neck. In that case I would have failed spectacularly and indeed often did, because there is no list that names Sepia as a remedy for the thyroid. And further: Sepia does belong to remedies that have a unilateral affinity, but usually this is the left side of the body. Again I would have been wrong.

The remedy Sepia was given to the patient because she was a typical Sepia patient with typical Sepia symptoms. I could not have given her anything else. I had the absurd intention of first curing the patient and then the goitre.

But if (and this is a big if) we succeed in curing our patients, there is usually not much left to be cured. Our task is to heal them; everything else is left to them. If we restore them to their normal state, they will have no reason to develop abnormal conditions. Nature does not dally with what is superfluous; she has the power to remove or develop something. If you provoke her often enough she will react and then you will try in vain to trim her back into shape. If you put her on the correct course she will put her house in order by herself.

Be assured that nothing exists without reason! And learn – as I did – from the tadpole, for this unassuming creature taught me much. For a long time I thought tadpoles drop their tails! That only shows we still have much to learn about absorption!

HASTY PRESCRIBING

One should best keep clear of hasty prescribing. If you take a lot of time at the beginning for each patient, you will spare yourself many problems. Conversely, if you want to save time at the outset you will invite many times as many problems into your practice. Once you have muddied the waters with a wrong prescription, how will you steer back into calm waters? The clinical picture no longer matches the symptom picture. A bad prescription usually leads to further – bad – prescriptions and often the case becomes hopelessly spoiled.

If you are unsure, give a placebo and wait. Hahnemann writes that it is best to give placebo for a week.

PRESCRIBING A REMEDY WHILE IMPROVEMENT CONTINUES

Even if you have found the correct remedy, the scope for error remains enormous. Among the heartbreaking and catastrophic errors is the repeated administration of a remedy as long as improvement continues. Two cases are engraved on my memory which I did not fully understand at first. And yet I repeat the same mistake again and again, for one of the hardest lessons in life is to do nothing and to wait. One almost waits for the smallest symptom with which we can justify a dose and thereby often ruin the case prematurely.

I remember well a case I did not understand at first, as I was still at the beginning of my career. It was a patient with a typical Aloe diarrhoea (I have unfortunately not been able to find my notes, so I refer from memory). I gave Aloe CM (either a single dose or two doses a week apart). When he returned he was considerably better, practically cured. I congratulated myself and homeopathy, of course, for it is a wonderful thing. I had found the right remedy and thought he should continue taking it for a while, as a prophylactic! It goes without saying that at the next appointment he was not so well. I prescribed the remedy more frequently (after all the first dose had worked so wonderfully). I overdid it – after all, homeopathy is a wonderful thing (I should have put my ‘homeopathy’ in quotation marks then) – and the patient never came back.

Since then that case has haunted me. At the time I thought the first prescription was a relatively easy matter. But I had not understood what I had to do with patients when they came to me a second and third time. The obvious doing-nothing did not yet belong to my repertoire. I learned that rather late.

Here the philosophy comes into play. Here homeopathy falters for lack of knowledge. And right here the young homeopaths who receive a different training will score points. They will not have to learn how best ‘not to do it’. They will be taught from the start when not to act! For there is one rule that is absolutely incontrovertible:

As long as improvement continues, do nothing. Only if you are absolutely certain that the prescribed remedy has ceased to act may you rework the case.

Wright has recently demonstrated this under the microscope for Tuberculinum, although Hahnemann established this rule more than a hundred years ago. And we, who call ourselves his ‘followers’, sniff contemptuously at his teachings and do not even trouble to understand this very doctrine.

Do not repeat a remedy while improvement continues. In acute cases this may mean minutes or hours (Hahnemann himself wrote about this) or in chronic cases days, weeks or even months – depending on the case and the remedy. Do not intervene while an improvement is detectable and rejoice in our scientific method. Unless you wish to belong to those whose efforts repeatedly fall flat and who have ‘tried homeopathy’.

I also recall another case very well: a 29-year-old patient admitted to the London Homeopathic Hospital with heart failure due to mitral regurgitation. I still have the records. I repertorised Arsenicum and gave Arsenicum CM on two consecutive days (Spigelia was given in the intervening night, which may have disturbed the remedy’s effect).

The effect verged on magic. Three days later (only four days after admission) the heart muscle had normalised and returned to its proper position.

The patient’s liver had also reduced in size – from 22.2cm to 15.8cm.

 

Margaret Lucy Tyler

 

Margaret Lucy Tyler, 1875–1943, was a British homeopath and a pupil of James Tyler Kent. In 1903, at the age of 44, she completed her medical state examination and then served for forty years until her death at the London Homeopathic Hospital. Margaret Tyler is among the most important homeopaths of our time. Her publications include, among others, the ‘Practical Guide to Homeopathy’ and ‘Homeopathic Drug Pictures’.

 --------------------------------

Source: https://hpathy.com/e-books/how-not-to-do-it-by-tyler-ml/how-not-to-do-it/

Photo Medical plants: Shutterstock_268000238_Copyright fotoknirps

 

 

 

von Narayana Verlag