Bismuthum muriaticum and the mother's threatened suicide
By Jan Scholten
The patient presents with depressive moods. A trigger for the depressive episodes is the patient's sister, who often talks to her about the past and the incest they had to endure with their shared brother. The patient herself had always been able to fend the brother off successfully, but her sister had not. Her sister blames her for everything, says she was not on her side and that it is easy for her to distance herself and think positively about the brother because she did not have to experience such things. Every time her sister raises the subject, the patient becomes depressed. She then feels heavy all over, with the sensation of heaviness concentrated particularly in the head. She then has headaches as if she were in a vice. She also has lower abdominal pain, worse from chocolate.
She recognises the same depressive feeling from her youth. When she was ten or eleven years old, her mother suffered from depression. There was an incident in which her mother told her she was going to take her own life and left the house. The patient was very frightened and followed her mother for a few hundred metres before the mother discovered her and sent her back home. For several hours she was in great fear and did not know whether her mother would return home. After this incident she lived in constant fear. She did not dare go to school any more, for fear of leaving her mother alone. She was terrified of coming home and finding her mother dead.
To prevent her mother from taking her own life, she began to help her mother and took on a large part of the household chores: she cleaned, cooked and did the laundry. She hoped that by making life easier for her mother in this way she would not take her own life.
Analysis
The major theme here is the mother's threatened suicide. The mother theme leads us to Muriaticum. This is confirmed by the Muriaticum themes of caring for the mother and household chores. Further confirmation is found in the patient's fear of losing her mother's care. The question now arises which Muriaticum will be the right one here. The themes of death and loss reminded me of Arsenicum, but Arsenicum does not have the theme of suicide and killing; those are themes of the Gold series. One might also think of Aurum here, a well-known remedy for suicidal intentions, but Aurum is in stage 11 and in that stage one does not give in so easily; one is more resilient. In stage 11 one has the feeling of being able to carry on; one is under stress, but one goes on. A suicidal thought only comes when one sees no way out and no possibilities left. Suicide comes into play when one has lost the strength and the power to turn things for the better. Examples of this are losing one's entire fortune on the stock exchange or a samurai who has lost power and honour. The theme of loss belongs to stage 15: in stage 15 of the Gold series stands Bismuthum and, in combination with the mother theme, this yields Bismuthum muriaticum.
Reaction
Four weeks after taking Bismuthum muriaticum MK the patient felt much better; the depression was almost gone. In the first week after administration of the remedy she was very tired, spent the entire week in bed and slept almost all the time. She only left the bed to prepare meals for the children. After a week she got up again and felt very well. The feeling of heaviness had disappeared and she felt so light that when walking she almost felt as if she were floating. Her sister's problems and complaints no longer troubled her. Notably, about one month after taking the remedy she experienced a strong craving for raw herring. For approximately eight weeks she had to eat raw herring twice a week. This was unusual for her because previously she had a strong aversion to any kind of fish and to herring in particular. Previously she could not pass a fish shop because she could not stand the smell of raw herring. After about two months the craving disappeared.
Category: Medicinal product
Keywords:
Bismuthum muriaticum, suicide, depression