Illegitimacy and Survival: a Case of Leprominium |
| |
by Genevieve Scase |
| |
Kate, a woman in her mid-50s, came in January 2011 with persistent skin problems. For 10 years she had dermatitis on her right calf, but recently the situation had deteriorated. She had several streptococcal and staphylococcal infections: first on the foot, then in the armpits, and at the time of the first consultation an acute rash on the nape of the neck. She had undergone a whole range of antibiotic and corticosteroid treatments without success.
|
| |

|
|
| |
She describes the rashes on her neck, under her arms and on her foot as hot and itchy, sensitive to wind, touch and water. The rashes are red, inflamed pustules full of pus. They feel “fiery” and she describes “a terrible itch with the urge to scratch everything.” Recently she has been extremely angry about problems in a close friendship, and she links this anger with the inflamed state of her skin. She fears the rash will spread everywhere. The chronic skin condition on her calf is dry and itchy and for the first time has affected the left calf as well. She feels vulnerable, fragile and self‑centred. When asked what the illness means to her, she replies: “It is ugly, a burden, too big a challenge, a weight inside me, something I want to hide or deny.” |
| |
Aetiology
The first staphylococcal rash occurred nine months earlier during a holiday with her partner, who otherwise lives with her husband and children to keep the family together. During the camping trip her partner had to leave unexpectedly for work‑related reasons. The rash on Kate’s foot broke out so alarmingly that she went to the local hospital emergency department.
Far from home and without her partner she experienced feelings of helplessness and overwhelming problems. As she reflected on this during the consultation she realised the whole episode had triggered deep‑seated childhood patterns.
She reports: “My central theme is illegitimacy, I feel different and separate from my family (in terms of parentage), and I have the sense that I cannot have what I want, cannot have the love I want. I could not understand the family dynamics, I simply wasn’t like them, I was different. I was the result of an affair. my mother’s husband’s name was put on the birth certificate, and it was never spoken about again. I didn’t know this until I was 24. I was very angry about it; it was my right to be informed. The whole family wanted to continue as if I weren’t different. Everything was kept secret, but I was treated differently: promises were never kept, my siblings received things I never got, and I didn’t have the same rights.
I have worked through a lot and have largely resolved it for myself. I feel uncomfortable when I cannot resolve something in a relationship, when I cannot understand someone’s reply or behaviour, or when my life is not functioning well. When that happens I become very frightened: I then try to control the other person, force them to speak or to listen. Everything begins to wobble and I can’t find firm ground under my feet. As a child it was the same: everything was confusing, traumatising and tense. I was a difficult child: rebellious, rude, uncooperative and naughty. People still often find me brusque and unfriendly. Now I know that when I am like that I have the need to defend myself from the world; I push people away and thus protect myself from the danger of being abandoned.
My father went to Canada, it was a catastrophe! He lives in a dysfunctional family. I went to visit him and we had a natural rapport and closeness, but his wife felt threatened and forced him to choose – I was rejected. It was important for me to see where I come from: he could understand parts of me that my family did not understand, but then he reinforced the old story. I don’t even know if he is still alive.
It’s all about acceptance and legitimacy. I realise it ultimately has to come from within. I struggle to feel like a legitimate member of society. I admire people who move forward socially. I take it personally when my social life is not going well, it can totally cripple me. Then I isolate myself and feel unloved, unnoticed and out of place. In recent years I have learned more about love; I have learned that it is possible to love unconditionally, and what can come from that. – That matters to me. I am only now learning that the love must be within me, that it must begin with me.”
Important clues in this case are premature greying of the hair (from 19), hot flushes in the menopause, a strong craving for sweets and a traffic accident she describes as “the biggest cut in my life”: “It showed me how vulnerable I am, and I received a lot of love and care.” |
| |
Prescriptions
Several well‑indicated remedies proved ineffective. Over the course of two months her condition, however, improved somewhat with Staphylococcus C 200. The rash on the nape healed and the chronic eczema on the calf improved; it “simmered” but continued beneath the surface. The rashes in her armpits initially cleared but later reappeared with vigour. She describes an itching that “feels as if it will never stop, the urge to stop it, and the fear that it will engulf me, like something foreign and unknown.” She feels her relationship is on the edge and is desperately trying to stabilise and legitimise it.
She also told me more about her mother’s life story: “She was frightened; she left her husband to live with the man she was already having an affair with. When she realised she was pregnant his passion quickly faded and the relationship was over. She tried unsuccessfully to have an abortion. In her despair she turned to her ex‑husband and discovered he was about to leave England to start a new life in New Zealand. As she had no choice she stayed with her parents until she could get a ship to New Zealand. If I had been a boy she would have put me up for adoption because I might have reminded her too much of ‘him’. My presence was a problem for her. To be legitimate is important for survival; one is wanted in this world and is provided for.”
After two months’ treatment I then prescribed Sulphur Q3, which matched several general symptoms and also covered the relationship issue, albeit somewhat simply. The response was positive. The hot flushes calmed, the rashes on the nape, under the arms and on the feet healed, and the intensity of the feelings about the relationship also normalised. She felt less driven and less governed by her emotions. The theme of legitimacy was no longer so dominant. She spoke of an inner voice, the voice of a friend.
Six months later Sulphur had taken effect and she returned to the clinic. The calf (from which her chronic dermatitis had originated) had become inflamed again, was itchy and weeping; she described the problem as “minimal but devilish” and could not stop scratching.
During the consultation we both expressed our disappointment at the incomplete healing process. I urged her to tell me everything I might not yet know. She then shared the following: “One thing scares me: I want soft smooth skin, but my deepest fear is that I will always have disgusting skin, and so I don’t like myself. It’s as if there are two separate selves: I look at the self I do not want to be, as if I could split something off from myself. It doesn’t feel good.” I asked her what the problem of disgusting skin was really about. She replied: “Someone who has disgusting skin is not attractive, no one wants to touch them, they are revolting and remain alone and isolated, as if there is a barrier between them and the world.” |
Leprosy |
What followed was for me a unique clinical experience, perhaps arising from my strong empathy with the patient. As she spoke, a strange and shameful feeling came over me; I felt nauseous, as if something inside me revolted. Fortunately I did not vomit, instead I felt compelled to ask: “Do you mean like a leper?” |
She went very pale and answered: “Yes, how did you know that? I wanted to say the word but I could not bear it. I have always been interested in lepers; I was morbidly fascinated by them.”
We sat for a moment in silence, quite astonished by this truth that had opened up to us: probably the simillimum in the form of Leprominium. We can easily see the strong similarities with many key concepts of the leprosy‑miasm, which supports the prescription. The guiding symptoms according to Rajan Sankaran are: disgust, isolation, scratching, loathing, seclusion, outcast. The materia medica and a few cases in ‘Homoeopathic Links’ also report a strong affinity to skin diseases and premature greying.
She responded excellently to Leprominium, initially in C30 and later in 10M, of which she has taken two doses over the last six months. The skin eruptions on the calf have for the first time in 10 years receded to the point where there is hardly a trace left. She reports an increased sense of well‑being and an expansion in her emotional life. She describes it as an “open inner window” that she can choose at any time instead of a negative emotional reaction or a negative thought pattern. Her self‑esteem, her presence and her sense of belonging to the world have changed. She no longer isolates herself; she sees no need to legitimise herself or her relationship externally, in which she feels happy. In short: she has accepted herself. |
| |
References
Sankaran R., Sankaran’s Schema 2007 Edition
König P., Homoeopathic Links; Winter 1996, Two Small Remedies
Vermeulen F., Synoptic Materia Medica 2 |