A comparison of the mechanistic and holistic worldviews shows that homeopathy as a holistic and non-material treatment method belongs to a different paradigm than scientific medicine and so cannot be judged according to the same standards of evidence. The author demonstrates that modern medicine has its own problems with evidence by looking at the example of the Cochrane scandal and the replication crisis. To resolve the opposition between matter and consciousness, the new ontological theory of Bernardo Kastrup is proposed.
KEYWORDS: Cochrane, decline effect, efficiency, evidence, hermeticism, holistic, materialism, observational study, paradigm, philosophy of science, potentisation, replication, similarity, worldview