Abbreviations: MG: Mahesh Gandhi; P: Patient; HG: Hand gesture. Cases have been shortened for readability.
Case 1
This case concerns a 45‑year‑old man who presented to the clinic because of his anxiety disorder. He has suffered from this anxiety disorder with panic attacks for 20 years and is being treated with psychotropic drugs. The patient traces his first panic attack back to his final exams in medical school. At that time he had to study 14 to 16 hours a day. He experienced palpitations and chest pain, which worried him greatly because he thought he had heart problems.
The patient recounted situations from his student days in which he was extremely stressed, for example during his placement on the leprosy ward when he was very afraid of becoming infected. Even the simplest procedures, such as a pleural tap on a tuberculosis patient, would make him tremble and anxious because he feared he might accidentally puncture the patient’s lung. He was also unable to give vitamin injections because he feared the patient might suffer an anaphylactic shock. His great fears regarding the alleged dangers of infectious medicine eventually led him to become a pathologist, because in his opinion that meant less stress and anxiety.
But even as a pathologist he could not really overcome his anxieties. Routinely he would send laboratory results to other labs for verification to reassure himself and calm his fears, even if that meant paying for the tests out of pocket. Despite this, he initially hoped to open his own practice after a year, which never happened. He began working in his father's practice, where obese patients were among those treated with Ayurvedic medicine. That seemed to the patient like a safe option. However, he still had to fight his anxieties there as well. Once, when he treated an overweight patient with a blood pressure of 140/100, he was convinced that the patient would have a heart attack at any moment. He imagined all manner of worst‑case scenarios, became extremely restless and phoned the patient every five minutes to inquire after his wellbeing.
Because this problem runs strongly through the entire history, I wanted to explore it more deeply to investigate the level of sensation.
MG: What is the worst that could happen?
P: "There could be a court case and these processes drag on for years. How can I live with uncertainty for years? I could be imprisoned and have to live with all the criminals in jail. I would then be sexually assaulted – what if I contract AIDS? Just the thought of that gives me palpitations, my mouth dries up, I have chest pain and I feel dizzy."
The patient describes himself as gentle, kind and peace‑loving. He is not a fan of hard work but enjoys life's comforts. He likes to fly kites. By nature he is somewhat cowardly, but he dreams of beating up all the scoundrels and being cheered by his friends for it. His wife thinks he makes too much fuss about little things and gets too upset about trifles. For example, once he had misplaced his mobile phone and was convinced that criminals would use his phone to order a murder and that he would be jailed for it. He constantly worried about being sexually abused in prison and contracting HIV there (at this point he even jumped up from his chair to take a deep breath).
This point in the history is very important: the patient talks about his palpitations and jumps up. We can almost see the anticipatory tension; it is expressed by palpitations and cramps etc.
.jpg)
P: "Whenever I travel and cannot move, I don't feel well. I don't like being confined. It's a dilemma: should I go or not?" His restlessness can be interpreted as an attempt to flee. "Should I go or stay? Whenever I have these symptoms, I have the urge to flee. Then I need someone to calm me down. These situations exhaust me."
He describes another situation in which he became panic‑stricken. His daughter was ill and the treating doctor asked him to collect the lab results three days later. The thought of having to wait three days for the results was unbearable. For him the problem was not that the results might be bad, but that he had to wait so long. The anticipatory tension is deadly for him. He experiences tightness in the chest, palpitations and a sense of constriction etc. The patient also reported that he has no problem travelling by bus or train as long as he can board immediately. But if he has to wait two days for the bus trip, he can hardly stand it. The waiting wears him down.
At this point in the case history we return to the subject of prison and waiting to see what appears.
P: "In prison many dangers lurk: I could be attacked by a homosexual and become infected. Court proceedings usually take a very long time. They proceed very slowly, but I need quick solutions. That would be very stressful for me." (HG: The hand moves jerkily. The patient takes a deep breath.)
"The uncertainty is very stressful for me. I don't know what will happen. I am always afraid that something will happen; the court proceedings overwhelm me completely. I would be entangled in them and it would drive me mad."
He describes his notion of being "entangled" and speaks in detail about court proceedings that go on for days during which people are repeatedly summoned. The slowness of these procedures would give him sleepless nights and make him very restless.
The patient's main problem and thus the essence of his personality is uncertainty, which triggers great fears in him. Uncertainty provokes anxiety, regardless of what the uncertainty concerns: anaphylactic shocks, lab results, Ayurvedic herbs or bus trips. The uncertainty is beyond his control and can extend over days, sometimes seemingly indefinitely. The restriction of movement, the deep inhalation, the jumping up from the chair and the jerky hand gestures he experiences in these situations or in his thoughts are characteristic of his nature. These features run through the entire case and become visible both physically and emotionally. The sensation that a patient has fully internalised and that is expressed on many levels is called the Vital Sensation.
In the present case we can see that the central theme for this patient is uncertainty about the future and fear of forthcoming events. In addition there is a fear of illness: he worries that he might become infected and perhaps contract AIDS (Acquired Immune Deficiency Syndrome). By nature he tends to be comfort‑seeking. Fundamentally he is a coward who, in his imagination, beats up others and boasts of his strength. This fear of the future and fear of illness – particularly contagious diseases – is a particular feature of Calcarea. (Ref: Despair about shattered health, hypochondriacal; despairing mood with fear of illness and misery, with foreboding of distressing events; fear of contagion, of loss of mind). [1]
There is another aspect in this case: the sensation of being constricted, cramped and entangled. This aspect corresponds to the essential sensation of Nitrogenium. [2]
Nitrogenium belongs to the lithium series (row 2 in the periodic table of the elements/mineral kingdom). The main theme of the mineral remedies is structure – the innermost core of one's own structure and the attendant need to fulfil all functions necessary to maintain that structure. This leads either to a lack of, or a loss of, the abilities required for the given functions. The themes revolve around the question "Am I able to do this, or not?" This question is vividly illustrated in the periodic table of the elements, since each series (row) represents a particular stage in human development. The main themes of the seven rows of the periodic table are as follows:
Row 1: Existence
Row 2: Separation
Row 3: Identity
Row 4: Security and duty
Row 5: Creativity and achievement
Row 6: Responsibility
Row 7: Decay [3]
In the lithium series everything, quite obviously, concerns separation from the mother. From left to right in the lithium series are the following elements: lithium, beryllium, boron, carbon, nitrogen (Nitrogenium), oxygen (Oxygenium) and fluorine. The remedies of this series correspond to different stages of human development from conception through maternal pregnancy to entering the world and the subsequent separation from the mother. Hydrogenium (hydrogen/row 1 of the periodic table) corresponds to the stage before conception up to the moment when ovum and sperm fuse. Remedies from row 2 therefore describe the sensation of adult people who, in their inner experience, still feel as if they are in the womb or in the state of separation from the mother. Each remedy of this row relates to an individual developmental stage. Nitrogenium, for example, stands on the right side of the row. People corresponding to this state describe an inner sensation of contraction, of being cramped, as actually happens during birth when passing through the birth canal. The patient's sensation corresponds to the birthing process.
In the present case the theme of uncertainty predominates. If one looks up Argentum nitricum in Rajan Sankaran's "The Soul of Remedies" we know that these patients cannot tolerate anticipatory tension, cannot tolerate excitement. This anxiety is the hallmark of the remedy. The uncertainty cannot be kept under control. This loss of control is a peculiarity of the right side of the lithium series.
So, on the one hand we recognise the characteristics of Calcarea here (fear of contagion and cowardice), on the other hand we have the uncontrollable uncertainty, constriction and entanglement of Nitrogenium on the right side of row 2 of the periodic table. Consequently Calcarea nitricum is the appropriate simillimum for the case.
Prescription: Calcarea nitricum C200, to avoid an initial aggravation.
Follow‑up: Six months later the patient reported feeling much better and more centred. The anxiety attacks had markedly decreased. Where previously little things had triggered a panic reaction, he now responded with calm. Family and friends had also noticed positive changes. He returned to the clinic because of bloating. A dose of his constitutional remedy also resolved this problem.
Case 2
This case concerns a 19‑year‑old young woman with epilepsy and panic attacks, treated with antiepileptic drugs and barbiturates. The mother, who accompanied her daughter to the appointment, told us that her daughter is afraid to leave the house alone because of her seizures. She feels noticeably better and more relaxed at home. Occasionally dizziness and an aura occur before a seizure. The seizures themselves are usually triggered by bright light, for example when watching television or using a computer. Rotating fans or the passing scenery in a train can also trigger an epileptic seizure. She then feels dizzy and describes the sensation as if the ground beneath her feet is being shaken by a slight earthquake.
Even the mere sight of a crowd puts her into a kind of trance in which her perception is severely restricted. The mother reported that the first seizure occurred at the age of 16, the second followed within six months. During the second seizure her eyes rolled and her neck turned to the left and the girl was unconscious for 15 minutes. After this incident the mother advised her daughter not to go out alone, which the daughter has not dared to do since then.
Because of her convulsions the young woman is very afraid of travelling. She fears that something might happen and there would be nobody to help her. At this point the patient spontaneously said that she is afraid of crowds and faints in such situations. She believes she is being watched by others; this thought terrifies her. She then falls into a trance‑like state; her eyes are open but her visual perception is severely limited. She therefore avoids crowds because these situations are very oppressive for her.
The patient then spoke about her exams, for which she prepares thoroughly, yet still feels she will be unable to answer the questions. She says she cannot attend classes because computer screens make her dizzy and this leads to a trance with reduced visual perception. Her mother is a great help to her, gives her confidence and supports her. Others do not understand her complaints, not even her father and brother. She is extremely hypochondriacal and fears diseases invading her body. She panics over minor things: for example, once she had a headache and panicked because she thought she had contracted leprosy and would die.
She is currently preoccupied with what career to pursue and is very undecided. She believes she is not normal and that other people consider her odd because something is wrong with her. She thinks people regard her as mentally deficient. She regards herself as an outsider who is very dependent on others, e.g. on her mother.
She dreams of travelling to many places, but cannot do so alone and relies on her mother's accompaniment. She also dreams of ghosts. She cannot look at blood; the sight makes her dizzy and she is afraid of witnessing an accident or a funeral. She cannot watch horror films and cannot bear the sight of a coffin. She has a great fear of cockroaches, lizards and dogs that might bite her.
The central theme in this case is clearly clinging and the need for support (mother) and moral backing. The patient feels understood only by her mother. She also expresses the feeling that there is something wrong with her, that she is not okay, perhaps mentally deficient. Her illness has taken away her self‑esteem. This is the language of the mineral kingdom – the young woman does not feel independent but is completely dependent on her mother.
Her individuality is further characterised by the experience that she will fall as soon as she is out alone; she needs her mother to hold on to. We thus note the patient's panic, which breaks out even over trifles and particularly whenever she is alone. This concerns mainly acute situations in which there is a need to cling. That is the essence of the present case. The panic is felt like an earthquake, as if the ground under the feet is unstable. This panic, which always occurs when one is alone, is a characteristic feature of the lithium series [4].
The second aspect of the case is confusion. The young woman does not know which path to take in life. Confusion is an important theme of the remedies located in column 3 of the periodic table (Alumina, Scandium, Yttrium – these patients are confused and doubt a lot). Another key aspect is the restricted visual perception repeatedly reported by the patient. This sensation symbolises the situation in the womb – one is completely enclosed and must suddenly go out. One does not yet know the new environment and tries to hold on to familiar things. The remedy in which this aspect is particularly pronounced – clinging in moments of panic as if the ground were being pulled away, coupled with confusion and restricted perception – is found in row 2 of the periodic table and column 3: Boron. [5]
Prescription: Boron metallicum C200
Follow‑up: The patient responded very positively to the remedy. The fear of leaving the house disappeared completely. She no longer feels abnormal. The epileptic seizures and trance‑like states stopped. She no longer needs medication. Her parents consider her to be 100% better.
Case 3
This patient constantly feels cramped, nervous and tense. When he has to do something for the first time he becomes very nervous; he cannot remain calm. After such a situation he feels nauseous, the palms of his hands and the soles of his feet sweat and he falls into panic. Everything feels blocked from the inside. Any situation can lead to cramping and tension, whether at work, while travelling or at a doctor's appointment, as now. By nature he is very impatient. He has very low self‑esteem and considers himself incompetent. He is very reluctant to begin a task because he believes he will do everything wrong. He clings strongly to other people because that gives him a feeling of security.
The cramping precedes a panic attack (he makes a gesture of cramping). It is like a wall standing before him. The opposite of this cramping is bliss and peace, as if there were no wall; then he can breathe freely. The sensation of being cramped (he takes the position of a foetus) he compares to a dark place in which he is stuck, where he is squeezed from all sides and cannot get out. It feels suffocating. The idea produces an unpleasant sensation in his stomach. In these situations he screams with rage and feels so much panic that he could smash through a wall. These are his words. His anger worsens when people do not listen to him and things get out of control. That increases the panic even more. With familiar people who care for him he feels safe. He then feels like he is in a secure circle in which he is protected from the outside world.
Dependence on others and inability to act are typical of the mineral kingdom. The sensation of being stuck, crushed and cramped in connection with panic is an indication of row 2. The remedy in which this sensation is central is Nitrogenium [6].
Prescription: Nitrogenium C200, once a week.
Follow‑up: Four months later the panic attacks had markedly improved. The feeling of tension and explosiveness had noticeably decreased.
Case 4
The 39‑year‑old patient began the initial consultation with the sentence: "I don't even know where to start." To her mind life was a single catastrophe. She worried about everything: her relationship, her finances, her work and much more. She had difficulty trusting other people. Physically she had been diagnosed with cholecystitis. She also suffered recurrent migraine headaches that improved in the dark. When she has headaches she demands fresh air and needs to dress warmly. She cannot sleep with the window closed. By nature she is very impulsive: she has sudden fits of anger that subside immediately. Another complaint is a foul‑smelling leucorrhoea.
The patient is very changeable and unable to plan; she never knows what she will be doing half an hour later. She cannot make decisions and cannot discriminate. When she looks at moving objects she becomes dizzy and nauseous.
When we asked her about the catastrophe in her life – which had been her opening words – she gave the example of her boyfriend: if he wanted to be alone for a while, she immediately thought he no longer loved her. That thought alone came close to the end of the world. As a child she had taken any criticism from her teachers so seriously that she would have preferred to stop going to school. Everything felt like the end of the world, a kind of "loss". She feels that she is a burden to others and worthless. She cannot distance herself from people who are close to her. She needs a lot of affection and attention; affection means warmth. Warmth means being hugged, like a mother's loving embrace. A hug means safety. In an embrace she feels safe from the outside world, which makes demands and in which one must prove oneself.
Quite suddenly and unexpectedly the patient said: "I always feel I have to change myself in order to be worth something. I try to be perfect – there is someone inside me who demands perfection. I want to be independent, to stand on my own feet and not be dependent on external support. Once I saw a toy – it reminded me of a globe, a closed but living system; it did not need support from the outside; I want to be like that."
.jpg)
A spontaneous association such as this we call a spontaneous association. This toy was a very surprising aspect that emerged here. Therefore we wanted to pursue the connection further and see where it led us.
The toy resembles a closed glass globe with living beings inside who depend on support from the outside world, e.g. food. In this experience it is about independence. Inside the closed globe one is safe from humiliation or the risk of being thrown out of one's home. The patient recounted an incident from her childhood when she was sent to her grandparents because she had been naughty. The patient had felt hurt and humiliated then, as if she had been thrown out of the house. At that time she did not want to go back home and would have run away into the woods forever if she had had her things with her. But then she became afraid of the dark, lonely wood. After this experience she tried to be as perfect as possible so that she would never be sent away again. Throughout her childhood she had been dependent on her mother and could not do anything alone. She had always wished to be loved by her mother as she was.
When the patient was asked to describe the toy more closely she said it was like a glass globe, similar to a closed goldfish bowl (HG: circle). "It is a safe place for a baby" (begins to cry), "it is like a hug. One is protected and receives care, tenderness and attention. It is like the unborn child's situation; it's like something the child has before birth but not afterwards."
At this point she made a connection to an article she had read in a magazine. It was about a baby in China that had been thrown out on the street like a sack of rubbish; it was totally helpless. She pictured how that baby must have felt – vulnerable and defenseless, exposed to deadly dangers. The patient said she had also felt "discarded" when she learnt of her husband's extramarital affair.
In this case there are two important aspects: firstly the experience in the womb and the aspect of primal trust, humiliation and respect. On the other hand the patient is completely dependent on others; she feels like she is in a glass globe that gives her security, protection, tenderness, care and love. At the same time she feels disappointed by her husband and by her mother because they tore her out of this protective shell. She experienced this as humiliating and disrespectful. This complete dependence, which corresponds to the dependence of a child in the womb, we find with Lithium. The disappointment, mistrust, humiliation and lack of respect are themes of Muriaticum (the element chlorine) [7].
Prescription: Lithium muriaticum C200, later a 1M was given.
Follow‑up: Six months later the panic attacks had markedly improved. The cholecystitis and the migraine had been cured. The feeling of dependency had also improved, although she still needs a lot of support. She had separated from her husband, a sign that she had become much more independent.
Case 5
A 27‑year‑old patient with panic attacks. She reports that all complaints began after her wedding. The decision to marry had been difficult for her. The wedding had taken place only a month earlier, to a man she had known for three years. For her he had long been part of the family, but she experiences the relationship as suffocating. Two years earlier they had been on holiday in Prague and she had been alone for an hour. She had felt panic and had become hysterical. She considers her boyfriend and now husband to be childish and inept.
Shortly after the wedding the two of them visited the patient's father in New York. One night she woke up and felt trapped in the marriage, seeing no way out. She immediately woke her husband and demanded a divorce in the middle of the night. She expressed her wish very clearly, but still sought the closeness of her husband, pulled him towards her and held him tightly. She does not find her husband attractive and often panics wondering why she is still married to him. She feels bound, suffocated, like a bird in a cage. She could only put on her wedding ring with great effort. The marriage means a loss of power to her. She has a great desire for freedom, to break out, to explode and to do great things. In her view the marriage prevents her from flourishing. She feels disconnected, not alive. She does not feel free: the feeling of constriction and tightening gradually takes her captive.
The patient then told of an event in her childhood: the father had molested a friend of hers who reported him. The father left the family and the patient had to take responsibility for her mother and siblings. The family told everyone that the father had gone abroad to earn money. She had to take on the role of head of the family. She hated that role and would have preferred to be independent and free. She felt bitter towards her family because she felt robbed of her childhood. She felt stuck and had "a hole in the stomach". Her lungs also felt tight; she had shortness of breath and her life seemed "stiff, like frozen". She put it like this: "I want someone to get me out of here."
Her hobbies include performing arts, acting and writing. When she pursues her hobbies she feels she can be herself; she then feels free like a bird, almost as if she could fly. The opposite of this feeling of freedom, she describes, is being locked up, stuck and imprisoned. She describes the feeling of being trapped as follows: "Being imprisoned in a plastic eggshell. It is very small and encloses me completely. I sit curled up, there is not enough space to stand up" (She takes the foetal position). "Everything is stuck, no air, I feel like I'm in a coffin."
The patient's main sensation was a feeling of suffocation, no air, being locked up, trapped and stuck, as if she were a foetus in the eggshell. This is a typical expression for patients who need a remedy from the second row. The construct resembles the womb, which for the patient no longer feels pleasant, warm and cosy, which leads us directly to the right side of the second row. Another pointer to the right side is the fact that she wants a divorce from the man who has actually been part of her family for over three years. We see that the energy of the case is focused on separation from the partner who, for her, belongs to the family. The patient's behaviour is very interesting when she demands a divorce from her husband: she clearly says she wants a divorce, but at the same time pulls her husband to her and clings to him. Consequently the themes of "clinging" and "separation" are represented here; the two terms form the main theme of the case. Lithium clings exclusively. Fluorine demands separation. Oxygenium has both – clinging and the desire for separation. [8]
Prescription: Oxygenium C200
Follow‑up: The panic attacks are much improved. She now has a healthy physical relationship with her husband. She has become the mother of a lovely little son. The feeling of suffocation has significantly decreased. She faces the demands of the world more positively than before. At last she feels like a woman. Her relationship with her sister and her mother has also improved. Words such as "imprisoned, suffocated, trapped" no longer belong to her vocabulary.
Summary of the lithium series:
In the mineral kingdom everything revolves around structure and the ability to act. The mineral kingdom represents a person's journey from birth to death. Each series symbolises the different phases (stages) a person passes through in life. A person who needs a remedy from the mineral kingdom is stuck at a certain point in their personal development.
It is important that we understand the lithium series, especially with regard to psychiatric illnesses. Practising psychiatrists can draw from a veritable treasure trove of wonderfully effective remedies here.
In the lithium series the birthing process and the separation of the infant from the mother/womb are reflected. All patients who need a remedy from this series need to be protected from the outside world. The world appears to them as threatening and frightening. An independent existence is experienced as unbearable. In my clinical experience all remedies from this series have a fear of downward movement. They have a poorly developed ego and are very fragile.
Lithium: Is like a foetus still completely dependent on the womb; the umbilical cord has not yet been cut.
Beryllium: Is like a nine‑month foetus who feels comfortable in the womb and does not want to go out. He/she is very content where he/she is.
Boron: At this point the birth begins, the first contractions start. The child is confused – should it stay or go? The world as previously known is shaken. This leads to a feeling of panic; he/she tries to cling on.
Carbon: The child has decided: it wants to go out. The head has entered the pelvis. The crucial question at this moment is: "Do I have enough strength to go out into the world?"
Nitrogen: Feels cramped and compressed in the birth canal and wants to get out as quickly as possible.
Oxygen: Represents the exit of the child from the birth canal and the first independent breath.
Fluorine: Represents separation, the moment when the umbilical cord is cut. Wants to be separated. This basic desire is expressed in the rubric "Delusion – Marriage – to dissolve, to get divorced; must divorce". [9]
The cases were compiled and edited by Sneha Vyas and Devang Shah.
Sources:
1 – Michael Hourigan and David Kent Warkentin, ReferenceWorks Pro, 4.2.1.1, Clarke’s Dictionary, Mind
2 – Rajan Sankaran, Structure, Volume 1, Row 2, Nitrogen
3 – Rajan Sankaran, Structure, Volume 1
4 – Rajan Sankaran, Structure, Volume 1, Row 2
5 - Rajan Sankaran, Structure, Volume 1, Row 2, Boron
6 - Rajan Sankaran, Structure, Volume 1, Row 2, Nitrogen
7 – Rajan Sankaran, Structure, Volume 1, Columns, Column 17 and Row 3, Chlorine
8 - Rajan Sankaran, Structure, Volume 1, Row 2, Oxygen
9 – For further references, Structure, Volume 1, Row 2
**************************************************************
Photos: Shutterstock
Green two‑way sign; iQoncept
Single soap bubble; PanicAttack
Category: Cases
Keywords: Anxiety disorder, panic attacks, schizophrenia, trauma, catastrophe, convulsions, confusion, hysteria, lithium series, suffocation, separation.
Remedies: Boron metallicum, Calcarea nitricum, Lithium muriaticum, Nitrogenium, Oxygenium
Original article: Interhomeopathy.org