
Danielle is a charming woman. She was born in 1952, is a Buddhist and a birdwatcher. She worked in her husband's financial investment firm but has little interest in that business. She wears her hair short and plain and has rosy, high cheekbones. Like many women in Seattle she dresses sporty and practical in an outdoor style.
I present this case as an example of a profound healing that did not occur overnight or from a single dose of a remedy, but must be understood as a development over several years. I want to show how patients can change through the long-term administration of a good remedy and how the therapeutic support — which in this case encouraged self-reflection — sets new standards for researching and recognising one’s own healing process.
(Editor’s note: This case report has been considerably shortened, but the core statements from the anamneses conducted over more than nine years have been retained as far as possible.)
March 2003 – the vocation for contemplation
Danielle (D): “My first priority is not my physical health. I have a vocation for contemplation. I would like to clarify for myself how I can have more joy and serve. But I am not balanced enough to address these things. Sometimes I cannot bear it (tears). Is it worth getting help?
“I have been a Buddhist since 1986 and practise two hours of meditation daily. I believe that homeopathy complements meditation.
“My father was huge – a deep voice full of anger. He threatened to beat us; he verbally abused us. I was very intimidated by him, but I kept resisting him. I was very afraid of him. I believed I deserved what he felt for me. When he was very old we had a close relationship. He died in November 2001. The night he died he became very restless when I visited. He expressed his hatred, his distrust and his negativity towards me. That put me in a state of sheer intimidation. Since his death I have been a wreck. I can accept what he ‘gave’ me. I cannot be with my friends because I am proud of living an honest life… ”
Krista Heron (KH): Living an honest life?
D: “Every friendship is built on a lie because they cannot stand me. I don’t trust them enough to tell them how fragile my mental state is. Underneath there is always a feeling of unworthiness. If I believed that my body and my mind would die if I jumped off a cliff, then I would do it. But I believe my mind would suffer. This self-absorption and this awareness of myself are so painful. I have found ways to lose myself. I can only feel joy when I go on long solitary retreats and my pain is uncovered in those moments.
“I feel inadequate, intellectually inferior, unattractive and socially awkward. As a teenager I hardly spoke. In my twenties I threw myself into work and married someone I didn’t like and therefore didn’t have to build a relationship with. Today I would never marry him. My husband doesn’t understand that.
“I have two sisters, both older than me. We look very similar physically, we all have plantar fasciitis. Mine comes from a damaged right sciatic nerve because of long periods of sitting during meditation. I grew up barefoot in the Philippines; I no longer go barefoot.
“I have constipation, my whole life, and I have haemorrhoids.
“I am prone to sinus infections and get colds that settle in the chest. When I drink milk my eyes and sinuses swell and I get a cold. I am also allergic to mould and have to sneeze and get an itch on the palate. Sometimes I have spring allergies and may be allergic to wheat. As soon as I eat less, these symptoms also subside.
“I also have circulation problems. My mother had high blood pressure, TIAs and minor strokes.
“As a child I often had flu with high fever; I was treated with penicillin. I used to run behind the lorry in the field while it sprayed pesticides.
“When I was small I was afraid of people. I didn’t speak to adults. I was a loner.
“My father worked for the Navy. Until I was 15 I lived on the naval base. Every two years the families changed, some left, others arrived. A few remained. I attended Catholic school.
“My mother was always extremely busy; everyone came to our home. She would put us all in the car and take us on outings. We were like a Girl Guides troop; she had little patience for babies; she treated us like adults.
“My parents’ relationship was terrible, yet she defended him. I felt betrayed by her. It became a battlefield between me and my father. I always knew my mother liked me. She was unable to come to terms with him… as I do in my marriage. We both have the positive quality of recognising that the other person suffers, and we voluntarily commit to not harming the other further, albeit at our own expense. It would hurt my husband if I left him.
“I never wanted to be in a relationship, but I kept finding myself in one; I even tried relationships with women. When I met Sam I knew I had to marry him. On our wedding day I hated him. He has so much power because I give it to him. There is an element of masochism here; it’s about letting go, not being drawn in. He is rude and selfish and yet I love him like my father. I feel bound, trapped, I want out. I looked into convents of nuns. I already have a husband who hates me and is dead; perhaps it wouldn’t be so bad to have another… There are no clear boundaries between my father and my husband. I take responsibility for what they feel. They think I am wrong and they are right.
“I want an open heart. I don’t want to be a burden to anyone.”
KH: The conflicts with your father?
D: “They were vicious. My whole life became a fight. Early on I slept with soldiers; I became what my father hated. I provoked my father to beat me. I felt schadenfreude and said: ‘Go on’. I felt such a terrible hatred that then turned against myself.”
KH: Recurring dreams?
D: “I am paralysed and someone in the room wants to kill me. I cannot wake up and flee.”
KH: Fears?
D: “That I will be violently killed by a man. As a child I had a fantasy in which I imagined leaving my body; I dissociated from the experience.
“Social situations are painful. I am afraid that people – even babies – will guess my worthlessness and will not respond to me, will not connect with me. I never wanted to have children.
“We don’t have sex; I have been sexually abstinent since 1989. At forty-five I had a hysterectomy because I had fibroids in the uterus; afterwards I had hot flushes. It was emotionally devastating. My reproductive window was gone, that very moment when children can come. I believe the womb is a nourishing, feminine organ.”
KH: Anger?
D: “I go quiet. I exclude people; I wall myself off.”
Prescription: Lac caninum 200
Analysis
I recognised that Danielle needed a milk remedy and identified some familiar terms that pointed to this specific milk: lie, mask and unworthiness.
Follow up
The remedy helped her overcome the depression and gave her the courage to carry on. Her need for comfort eating decreased. Some time later the depression returned, she questioned herself and practised self-criticism. “Why can’t I love Sam? What is wrong with me? Why don’t I do in my life what I like? I feel stupid when I ask for help.”
Prescription: Lac caninum 200 and then 1M helped her on the emotional level.
D: “I feel emotionally better, I accept my anger and rage more. I don’t judge myself so much any more.” Physically only her allergies improved. In the months that followed she continued to struggle. “I’m so afraid of saying something wrong or something stupid. The message behind it is self-hatred. I decided from the start that I would not be good at anything I love. That’s why I work in administration and earned a reputation for being competent. I am really constricted; I am shy and mistrustful. I am afraid of failing because I am not smart enough or empathic enough.”
In March 2004, among other indications, Lac defloratum was given because of a longing to enter a monastery, to endure insults and yet give to others.
April 2004 – relapse into depression
D: “I have a strong craving for milk.
“I am plunging into depression. I link my life with my mother’s: she, like me, had low self-esteem. There are remarkable parallels: her mask that allowed no one to really know her; what she felt for her husband; she had few friends but many people liked and admired her; they considered her competent. She was depressed but had an incredible resilience. I am afraid that my own resilience will win out; that none of it has anything to do with my father or with Sam; it is really just fear, low self-worth and the suffering of having to remain alive. There is little reason for joy in everyday life.
“I have always perceived my physical body as disgusting. I feel fat and ugly, especially my thighs. I had a dream. A bus driver looked at me and drove away. I felt cut off from everyone.”
Prescription: Lac humanum 200
Analysis
It is entirely clear that Lac defloratum was not right: she plunges into depression and feels she has to endure her miserable life – like a very heavy burden. She feels even more cut off, as shown by the dream. However, she still needs a milk remedy because she draws parallels between her mother’s life and her own and has a pronounced craving for milk.
June 2004
In the following months she improved on many levels.
D: “My self-confidence is greater and I no longer scourge myself so much, my self-disgust has also decreased. I feel as if I am finding my way back to myself. Sam and I understand each other so much better. I am trying to let go of the victim role.
“My plantar fasciitis has almost gone; I have more energy, and the constipation and headaches have improved. I no longer sit cross-legged for meditation, so my sciatica complaints have improved.”
A year later she questioned her relationship again.
April 2005
D: “There is not a day when he doesn’t criticise me. I increasingly feel trapped. I can't just create something that isn’t there. It is comparable to asking how I can love Israel when I am in Palestine.
“I don’t feel self-hatred; I no longer injure myself. My relationships with my friends have improved.
“I am afraid of loneliness. I don’t trust my own decisions; I almost court being hurt again. The remedy has allowed me to see the good in Sam.”
Her depression recurred: she felt unseen and unheard, hopeless and cut off. Nevertheless she began to reflect more on herself – in a healthy way.
D: “Previously I felt that nothing could get better, now I know why I wasn’t liked. Some of it I deserved, some of it was because my self-centredness was misunderstood. I used to steamroller people, devalue them when I considered their ideas unworthy. Now I feel I have more understanding for how I can be someone who cares and is cared for.
“My heels are sore, my back hurts, I have constipation and allergies. I can’t stop eating dairy products.”
After briefly giving her Lac caninum again, I prescribed Lac humanum 1M.
August 2005
D: “I almost didn’t come because I feel so well. Immediately after taking the remedy my constipation was better, my feet improved and so did my depression.
“I fed my mother. She can’t feed herself any more because of her stroke. Sometimes I eat from her spoon.
“I now see the world differently. The worry that people don’t like me is crumbling. I am more in touch with my honest feelings. My mother has become more real to me. I feel less guilty saying no to her; I like her; I feel gratitude towards her; I no longer feel called to manage everything for her. My personality is expanding. There is a side of me that I have integrated. I want to be called Danni. I will be more combative. I can be caring, but that is not my strong suit. Previously that would have embarrassed me, now it is simply so.”
Over the following months she says: “As far as general happiness is concerned, I am wonderful. I feel so much compassion. A lot has changed in the past year. I have been exposed to a constant storm of negativity my whole life, and now I am aware of changing that.”
In the meantime she decided to separate from her husband.
D: “It is wonderful, but at the same time I am upset and uncertain. Sam wants to talk, I just want it to be over. It is difficult to talk about money. Previously I longed for either him or me to die.
“My allergies are severe again, but my neck is better. My sciatica has returned.”
Prescription: Lac humanum 10M
In the months that followed there were ups and downs in the relationship with her husband.
D: “Sam and I are trying again. He was at a retreat and I was sad. I was lonely; I only had the cat.
“I don’t trust him enough. I am more open, less intimidated. I don’t want a bond with him. I feel a lot of affection, but also a lot of aversion.
“I can also see Sam as a real person, someone I don’t have to reject because he is not what I want him to be. I will get fierce, and he withdraws. I am taking small steps.”
In the meantime her mother died. Her relationship with her religious organisation changes over time, as do those with her friends.
D: “I practice my religion through my meditation, not within the organisation. It behaves like the Catholic Church: there is only the ‘one’ way. Gradually I am slipping out of the roles I have in the organisation.
“I make more friendships. I am more available. I take risks. I am aware that I am different.”
March 2009
D: “I often experience a ‘deep sense of well-being’, which is new to me. I feel more joy at being alive. I have never yet done meaningful work. I still have the feeling that I cannot leave. I increasingly do what I really want to do. I am still amazed that anyone wants to be friends with me, but I can feel it without getting caught up in it.”
September 2009
D: “I want to really tell people that I love them. I didn’t do that before. I have become more loving.”
At this time Lac humanum 10M was repeated as needed, then Lac humanum 50M.
February 2010
D: “Now I have friends and I talk to them. That was a big change. I don’t just talk to my friends, I also make new friends. My practice without panic attacks has become completely different. I have dissolved many old patterns.”
April 2010
D: “I see myself in the world differently ... I never noticed that I am angry when I am depressed. Now I don’t want to put on a mask any more.”
November 2010
D: “I think this is a good time to leave Sam.”
It takes more than a year before this actually happens.
July 2011
D: “I worked at the retreat house. It is a difficult place to work. People pigeonhole you, they think about where you stand with your spiritual practice; they believe you are greater than you really are. I feel a need to advocate for community, organic food and sustainable living. It is a driving force to do something that is truly useful for the planet. So it is also with meditation; the planet needs it.”
October 2011
D: “I am ashamed of my self-righteousness. I can block all communication. I feel that they are wrong, and so I come across as judgemental. I think people might feel bullied.”
December 2011
D: “My practice is more relaxed; blockages are dissolving. It has been a long time since I wished to be dead. I have always sought the hardest path and gone through it, but now I have found myself, without the background chatter that tells me I have to do something. I have been attracted to someone, but I fear it could be a trap, falling into another’s life and doing what they do.”
January 2012
D: “This morning I had a dream: I was walking with a friend in a rural area and thought we were being followed by a group of men. As we went down into a wood, I caught hold of an elf boy and put my hand over his mouth. He did not resist. As the men passed, they looked down into the wood and one of them looked at the boy in my arms and said, ‘Hello David’. So I took my hand off the boy’s mouth, and he asked if he could walk in the moonlight, and I said yes, then I woke up. That is how I slid from fear into life.”
Analysis
This is an interesting dream: she is with a friend (whereas in her dreams she is usually alone). They are being pursued by men (one of her greatest fears). She catches a boy who does not struggle (this boy seems to be a part of herself: it is noteworthy that both her name and the boy’s sound similar). The threatening men see the boy in her arms and say “Hello” (a non-threatening action). The boy is released and asks to walk in the moonlight – a sweet, relaxed image. When she wakes, she has the feeling of being freed from fear and able to stand in life.
April 2012
D: “When a person changes, everything changes. Sam has a lot of respect for my space, we are friends. He gently points out my black-and-white thinking, whereas I used to avoid that.
“I no longer meditate two hours a day and I no longer worry about what the organisation demands. I am aware that I describe the organisation as negative in order to be able to leave it. I don’t feel the need to burn bridges or push anything of mine away.
“My sister seems fed up with me. I dreamed twice that she dies. In one dream we walked through a frozen landscape. She turned to disagree with me and then slid under the ice. I thought ‘she will die’ and then she froze on the spot.”
Dream analysis
The frozen landscape is most likely an image of her difficult family environment.
The moment the sister disagrees (asserts herself), she slips under the ice; that is the risk Danielle fears – that if she disagrees and sets boundaries she will be trapped and frozen in place. I see this dream as an expression of healing and as an indication of the next self-image she needs to integrate.
October 2012
In the months that follow she continues to develop.
D: “My dreams lately are about feeling more at ease with the masculine aspect of life. Dreams are among the things I always suppressed, so it is good to have them back in my life. My dreams represent the struggles between my two names: Danni and Danielle. I used to think it was merely about masculine and feminine, but for me Danni is deeper, more intuitive, introverted, the one who stays. Danielle is more of a mask; she is unhappy about not being in tune with culture. Now there is a third name – Daniella – she is softer, someone who reaches out more to people. I feel a quiet joy inside; I feel more.
“I am now able to relate to people in a way I never could before. I am becoming increasingly kind and feel more connected to others; I find that nourishing. I feel a sense of community with myself and with others – more a sense of abundance than lack. I am almost no longer at the centre.”
January 2016
The patient continues to do well. I meet her occasionally and regularly hear from her friends who tell me how well she is.
Comment
Since 1996 I have studied with Massimo Mangialavori, and much of what I recognise in our remedies I see through his perspective, complemented by my own experience from almost thirty years of practice. We have collaborated on many projects, and in the last five or six years we have, together with Dr Betty Wood and John Sobraske, written his Materia Medica Clinica. The first publication of this series deals with the milk remedies.
Massimo suggests that there are three motives or observations that one can easily make at first encounter with a Lac humanum patient: abandonment, false oblativitiy[1] (a word Massimo uses to suggest a giving or altruistic nature in which the focus is not on the self but on others) and ambition. Danielle spoke about these motives in different ways. In the first case history she says: “I would like to clarify for myself how I can have more joy and serve...”. Later she says: “My main problem is doing what I am called to do; I avoid intimacy with myself and get entangled in tasks rather than following my bliss.” And: “My heart doesn’t know how to act rightly. I fear being selfish, making a decision out of egoism rather than doing what’s right for everyone.” We see this theme of serving, self-commitment and ambition, which demonstrates healing and restoration, in her later statement “I feel a need to advocate for community, organic food and sustainable living. It is a driving force to do something that is truly useful for the planet. So it is also with meditation; the planet needs it.”
Massimo also outlines four fundamental themes to be considered in patients who need a milk remedy:
Familial identity
The patient has difficulty seeing her life and identity separately from her family; instead she is still entangled with and defined by it. For these people their own parents remain the determining reference point. They also have an ambivalent relationship to individuation. They ask themselves: “Should I become an independent personality? Will I disappoint my parents if I do? Is it even possible to be my own person? Do I know who I am? Can I separate from them, cut the umbilical cord?” Massimo often finds that his patients who respond to milk remedies come from an overprotective family. I have, however, seen both: families where there was extreme neglect and abuse, and others who wanted to keep the child/adult close and undifferentiated.
This theme is expressed in the initial case by the following statements:
“The night he died he became very restless when I visited. He expressed his hatred, his distrust and his negativity towards me… Since his death I have been a wreck… I believed I deserved what he felt for me. I can accept what he ‘gave’ me.”
“I link my life with my mother’s: she, like me, had low self-esteem. There are remarkable parallels: her mask that allowed no one to really know her; what she felt for her husband; she had few friends but many people liked and admired her; they thought her competent. She was depressed but had an incredible resilience. I am afraid that my own resilience will win out.”
“I became what my father hated. I provoked my father to beat me. I felt schadenfreude and said: ‘Go on’. I felt such a terrible hatred that then turned against myself.”
“... I love him [my husband] like my father. I feel bound.”
And then, at follow up, she says: “I don’t know the right steps, I can’t walk or – like my mother – can’t speak.”
Abandonment
Patients who need a milk remedy often experience or fear abandonment. They feel or fear being separated from their family or others, and this is often associated with a feeling of unworthiness or inadequacy.
In this case Danielle tells us: “She had little patience for babies; she treated us like adults.” And: “I am afraid that people – even babies – will guess my worthlessness and will not respond to me, will not connect with me.”
Later she says: “I fed my mother. She can’t feed herself any more because of her stroke. Sometimes I eat from her spoon.” ... “My mother has become more real to me. I feel less guilty saying no to her; I like her; I feel gratitude towards her; I no longer feel called to manage everything for her.” And when she speaks about her surrogate family, her sangha: “Gradually I am slipping out of the roles I have in the organisation.”
Instinctive integration
These patients have difficulty expressing themselves, for example when they are angry or intimate; simply having their own needs or desires can provoke an internal conflict. They fear that by having these they will jeopardise their familial relationship, which could lead to separation and abandonment. And because life is about serving ideals, they feel conflicted as soon as they have a personal need, because they interpret this as selfish.
Danielle illustrates this theme with the following statements: “... married someone I didn’t like and therefore didn’t have to build a relationship... On our wedding day I hated him.” And at follow up: “For me every joy becomes work.”
Indecision
We also see indecision where the patient struggles with the question of who she is: Should I be who I am or be what my mother wants me to be? Should I be an idealised child? Should I break out and shape my own destiny? Is it even possible to do so?
When I ask Danielle about her dreams she reports: “I am not awake, but I am not asleep either. I fear I cannot move. I struggle out of sleep and cannot move. I am paralysed and someone in the room wants to kill me. I cannot wake up and flee.” We see in this statement her indecision about leaving her family and that she would put herself in great danger if she fled. We also see her indecision when she says: “I know what I want to do, but I don’t do it. My life is like it is blocked.” And we see how this indecision hardens when she reports, after taking the remedy for a while: “I want to be divorced by the end of the year. I know I won’t go back.”
In addition to the fundamental themes, Massimo lists characteristic themes that help differentiate the various milk remedies. The characteristic themes for Lac humanum are:
Ambition / dissatisfaction
My patient was dissatisfied with her life. She felt she should do more but felt inhibited from taking a leading role. Yet she could be assertive, or rather aggressive. She wondered whether she was really a tyrant. She tells us: “I feel inadequate, intellectually inferior, unattractive and socially awkward.” And: “I decided from the start that I would not be good at anything I love.”
Undeservedness
She felt very unworthy and inadequate, although especially within her sangha she received much recognition. She says: “He threatened to beat us; he verbally abused us. I was very intimidated by him, but I kept resisting him. I was very afraid of him. I believed I deserved what he felt for me… I can accept what he ‘gave’ me.” And: “Every friendship is built on a lie because they cannot stand me… Underneath there is always a feeling of unworthiness… Everyone wears a lot of masks.” And further: “I’m so afraid of saying something wrong or something stupid.” The underlying message is self-hatred.
Later we see this symptom in her statement: “My self-confidence is greater and I no longer scourge myself so much... I feel no self-hatred; I do not injure myself anymore. My relationships with my friends have improved.” And she continues: “Previously I felt that nothing could get better, now I know why I wasn’t liked. Some of it I deserved, some of it was because my self-centredness was misunderstood. I used to steamroller people, devalue them when I considered their ideas unworthy. Now I feel I have more understanding for how I can be someone who cares and is cared for.”
Rigidity / laxity
Rigidity appears in this case too. Certainly she chose a spiritual path that is very rigid, and somatically she had some complaints in the cervical spine. She reports: “I am really constricted; I am shy and mistrustful. I don’t trust that I will be liked or treated kindly, or that I am good enough. I feel constricted in my chest, my stomach and my lower abdomen.” And we see that her inner wound was healed after the remedy when she says: “The remedy has allowed me to see the good in Sam.”
Passive congestion
Danielle’s congestion shows itself in her constipation, her sinuses and her fibroids. When she first came to us she said: “I have constipation my whole life, and I have haemorrhoids. I can go days without much water passing.” And at follow up: “My physical symptoms feel the same as what is going on in my head. I feel blocked.” Danielle also reports a common aggravation found with milk remedies: “When I drink milk my eyes and sinuses swell...”
Almost two and a half years later Danielle confirms the correct remedy choice and successful prescription with the comment: “I almost didn’t come because I feel so well. Immediately after taking the remedy my constipation was better, my feet were better and my depression too.”
Fullness/emptiness
This theme can sometimes manifest as bulimia. My patient had problems with overeating and practised comfort eating which she found problematic.
Symmetry / asymmetry
With milk remedies we often see unilateral tendencies, for example the headaches of Lac caninum that can shift from one side to the other. This symptom reflects a deeper theme of duality: two sides, self and family, selflessness and selfishness. We see this in Danielle’s statement: “There is a side of me that I have integrated. I want to be called Danni. I will be more fierce. I can be caring, but that is not my strong suit. Previously that would have embarrassed me, now it is simply so.”
The first book of Massimo Mangialavori’s Materia Medica Clinica is called Homoeopathic Milk Remedies. It contains information on the source substances, a Materia Medica and two case examples for each remedy. The Materia Medica includes a list of the most frequent complaints, an in-depth examination of motives, the fundamental and characteristic themes and group analyses of symptoms. The personality structure and a differential diagnosis for each remedy are also discussed. The remedies covered in the book are: Lac caninum, Lac felinum, Lac vaccinum defloratum, Lac equinum, Lac caprinum, Lac delphinum, Lac glama, Lac asinum, Lac ovis, Lac suis, Lac lupinum, Lac leoninum, Lac humanum and Lac loxodonta africana.
[1] An Introductory Dictionary of Lacanian Psychoanalysis by Dylan Evans
... “Oblativitiy”, a term used by some psychoanalysts to denote a mature form of love in which one loves the other person for who they are, not for what they can give....

